managementranepaУправленческое консультированиеAdministrative Consulting1726-11391816-8590Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration. North-West Institute of Management.managementranepa-29Research ArticleОБЩЕСТВО И РЕФОРМЫSOCIETY AND REFORMS«Мировое гражданство» глазами его критиков (пять аргументов против «насыщенного» космополитизма М.Нуссбаум)“World Nationality” by Eyes of it’s Critics (Five Arguments against “Saturated” Cosmopolitism of M. Nussbaum)АкоповС. В.AkopovSergey Vladimirovichnoemail@neicon.ruНациональный исследовательский университет «Высшая школа экономики»National Research University “Higher School of Economics”20151604201802107114Copyright © Акопов С.В., 20182018Акопов С.В.Akopov S.V.Данная работа распространяется под лицензией Creative Commons Attribution 4.0.This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.https://www.acjournal.ru/jour/article/view/29

Задачей данной статьи является обзор и анализ критики мирового гражданства через призму политической философии коммунитаризма, неомарксистского мир-системного анализа, либерального национализма и традиционализма.

The objective of this article is the review and critique of the analysis of global citizenship through the lens of political philosophy of communitarianism, neo-Marxist world-system analysis, liberal nationalism and traditionalism.

космополитизммировое гражданствокритикапатриотизмсosmopolitanismworld citizenshipcriticismpatriotismReferencesВаллерстайн И. Анализ мировых систем и ситуация в современном мире. СПб. 2001.Wallerstein I. World-Systems Analysis and a situation in the modern world [Analiz mirovykh sistem i situatsiya v sovremennom mire]. SPb., 2001.Валлерстайн И. Ни патриотизм, ни космополитизм // Логос. № 2(53). 2006. С. 126-127.Wallerstein I. Neither patriotism, no cosmopolitism [Ni patriotizm, ni kosmopolitizm] // Logos, N. 2(53), 2006. P. 126–127.Нуссбаум М. Космополитизм и патриотизм // Логос. № 2(53). 2006. C. 110-119.Nussbaum M. Cosmopolitism and patriotism [Kosmopolitizm i patriotism] // Logos. N 2(53), 2006. P. 110–119.Патнэм Х. Должны ли мы выбирать между патриотизмом и универсальным разумом? // Логос. № 2(53). 2006. С. 120-125.Putnam H. Do we have to choose between patriotism and universal reason? [Dolzhny li my vybirat’ mezhdu patriotizmom i universal’nym razumom?] // Logos. N 2(53), 2006. P. 120–125.Тэйлор Ч. Почему демократия нуждается в патриотизме // Логос. № 2(53). 2006. С. 130-131.Taylor Ch. Why the democracy needs patriotism [Pochemu demokratiya nuzhdaetsya v patriotizme] // Logos. N 2(53), 2006. P. 130–131.Уолцер М. Сферы привязанности // Логос. № 2(53). 2006. С. 128-129.Walzer M. Spheres of attachment [Sfery privyazannosti] // Logos. N 2(53), 2006. P. 128–129.Хантингтон С. Кто мы? Вызовы американской национальной идентичности. М., 2004.Huntington S. Who are We? The Challenges To America’s National Identity [Kto my? Vyzovy amerikanskoi natsional’noi identichnosti]. M., 2004.Calhoun G. The Class Consciousness of Frequent Travelers. Toward a Critique of Actually Existing Cosmopolitanism // South Atlantic Quaterly. 2002. 101(4). P. 869-897.Calhoun G. The Class Consciousness of Frequent Travelers. Toward a Critique of Actually Existing Cosmopolitanism // South Atlantic Quaterly. 2002. № 101(4). P. 869–897.Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy: Nationalism and Global Justice - David Miller and His Critics. Vol. 11, № 4. 2008.Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy: Nationalism and Global Justice — David Miller and His Critics. Vol. 11, № 4, 2008.Held D. Cosmopolitanism. Ideas and Realities. London, 2010.Held D. Cosmopolitanism. Ideas and Realities. London, 2010.Kymlicka W. Citizenship in the Era of Globalization // The Cosmopolitanism Reader / G. W. Brown. D. Held (еds.). Polity, Cambridge, 2010. P. 435-443.Kymlicka W. Citizenship in the Era of Globalization // The Cosmopolitanism Reader / G. W. Brown. D. Held (еds.), Polity, Cambridge, 2010. P. 435–443.Kymlicka W. From Enlightenment Cosmopolitanism to Liberal Nationalism // Politics in the Vernacular: Nationalism, Multiculturalism, and Citizenship. Oxford. 2000. P. 203-220.Kymlicka W. From Enlightenment Cosmopolitanism to Liberal Nationalism / Politics in the Vernacular: Nationalism, Multiculturalism, and Citizenship. Oxford. 2000. P. 203–220.Kymlicka W. Liberalism. Community and Culture. Oxford. 1991.Kymlicka W. Liberalism. Community and Culture. Oxford. 1991.Miller D. Citizenship and National Identity, Polity, Cambridge. 2000.Miller D. Citizenship and National Identity. Polity, Cambridge. 2000.Miller D. Cosmopolitanism // The Cosmopolitanism Reader / G. W. Brown. D. Held (еds.). Polity, Cambridge, 2010. P. 377-392.Miller D. Cosmopolitanism // The Cosmopolitanism Reader / G. W. Brown. D. Held (еds.), Polity, Cambridge, 2010. P. 377–392.Taras R. Europe Old and New: transnationalism, belonging, xenophobia. Lanham, 2009.Taras R. Europe Old and New: transnationalism, belonging, xenophobia. Lanham, 2009.

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest present.