Juvenile Justice: Risks of Implementation
Abstract
Analysis of juvenile justice in the West shows that this system significantly expands the law court and social services while limiting the rights of parents. Social services can invade any family and formal criteria to take the child. The Central ideological category governing relations between parents and children is the priority of the rights of children above the rights of parents. Based on the analysis of the views of foreign and Russian experts on the subject showing the risks and threats of the introduction of a juvenile justice system in Russia, the negative effects of removal of children from families.
About the Author
Galina Mihailovna Tsinchenko
North-West Institute of Management - branch of the Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
References
1. Ananian L. L. Criminality of minors in the Scandinavian countries [Prestupnost’ nesovershennoletnikh v skandinavskikh stranakh]. M.: Science [Nauka], 1974. (rus).
2. Bazarov R.A. Criminality of minors: criminal violence, counteraction measures [Prestupnost’ nesovershennoletnikh: kriminal’noe nasilie, mery protivodeistviya]: Scientific publication. Yekaterinburg: Ekaterinburg Higher School of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia [Ekaterinburgskaya vysshaya shkola MVD Rossii], 1995. (rus).
3. Bezrukova O. N., Samoylova V. A., Ivashkina Yu. Yu., Kurganova G. S. Transformation of models of a family and parenthood and conceptualization of family policy [Transformatsiya modelei sem’i i roditel’stva i kontseptualizatsiya semeinoi politiki] / Sociology and society: global challenges and regional development: Materials of the IV Russian sociological congress [Sotsiologiya i obshchestvo: global’nye vyzovy i regional’noe razvitie: Materialy IV Ocherednogo Vserossiiskogo sotsiologicheskogo kongressa]. M.: RSS, 2012. 1 CD ROM. http://www.ssa-rss.ru/files/File/ congress2012/part22.pdf (date of the address 22.12.2013) (rus).
4. Beck U. Society of risk. On the way to other modernist style [Obshchestvo riska. Na puti k drugomu modern] / translation from German. V. Sedelnik and N. Fedorova. M.: Progress-Tradition [Progress-Traditsiya], 2000. (rus).
5. Belyaeva L. I. Formation of domestic school of the prevention of crimes of minors (the middle of XIX — the beginning of the XX century) [Stanovlenie otechestvennoi shkoly preduprezhdeniya prestuplenii nesovershennoletnikh (seredina XIX — nachalo XX v.)] // Questions of Juvenile Justice [Voprosy yuvenal’noi yustitsii]. 2007. No 3 (12). (rus).
6. Berger B. The nuclear family as a civilization fundamental principle in historical prospect [Nuklearnaya sem’ya kak pervoosnova tsivilizatsii v istoricheskoi perspective] // Bulletin of the Moscow State University. Series 18. Sociology and political science [Vestnik Mosk. Un-ta. Seriya 18. Sotsiologiya i politologiya]. 2003. N 1. P. 98. (rus).
7. Bondarenko N. N., Medvedeva I. Ya., Shishova T. L. Creeping revolution. An analytical note on a problem of juvenile justice implementation in the Russian Federation [Polzuchii gosudarstvennyi perevorot. Analiticheskaya zapiska po probleme vvedeniya v RF yuvenal’noi yustitsii]. 2009. URL: http://www.kreml.org/other/230767157. (Date of the address 23.11.2013) (rus).
8. Borisov N. E. Juvenile justice in Russia: formation problems [Yuvenal’naya yustitsiya v Rossii: problemy stanovleniya]. M.: Manuscript, 1998. (rus).
9. Bocharov Yu. M. The first special courts on cases of juveniles in Russia [Pervye osobye sudy po delam o maloletnikh v Rossii] // Children criminals [Deti-prestupniki] / Under the editorship of M. N. Gernet. M.: Publishing house “V. I. Znamensky and Ko” [Izd-vo «V. I. Znamenskii i Ko»], 1912. (rus).
10. Vishnevsky A. G. Evolution of a family in the USSR and the principles of family policy [Evolyutsiya sem’i v SSSR i printsipy semeinoi politiki] // Family and family policy [Sem’ya i semeinaya politika] / Collection of articles. Under the edition of A. G. Vishnevsky. Demography and sociology [Demografiya i sotsiologiya]. V. 1. M.: ISESP RAS [ISEPN], 1991. (rus).
11. Gernet M. N. Children criminals [Deti-prestupniki]. M.: Publishing house “V. I. Znamensky and Ko” [Izd-vo «V. I. Znamenskii i Ko»], 1912. (rus).
12. Gernet M. N. Criminality abroad and in the USSR [Prestupnost’ za granitsei i v SSSR]. M.: Soviet Legislation [Sov. zakonodatel’stvo], 1931. (rus).
13. Giddens A. Sociology of the 90th [Sotsiologiya 90-kh]: tutorial. Chelyabinsk, 1999. (rus).
14. Gurevich S. A. Responsibility of young criminals in the Russian legislation [Otvetstvennost’ yunykh prestupnikov po russkomu zakonodatel’stvu] // Children criminals [Deti-prestupniki] / under the editorship of M. N. Gernet; M.: Publishing house “V. I. Znamensky and Ko” [Izd-vo «V. I. Znamenskii i Ko»], 1912. (rus).
15. Guskova A. N., Yemelyanov V. A., Yurchenko L. V. Criminal procedure questions of the organization of juvenile legal proceedings in modern Russia [Ugolovno-protsessual’nye voprosy organizatsii yuvenal’nogo sudoproizvodstva v sovremennoi Rossii]. Orenburg: Publishing center of the OSAU [Izd. Tsentr OGAU], 2009. (rus).
16. Karnozova L. M. Juvenile justice: the content of concept and prospects in Russia [Yuvenal’naya yustitsiya: soderzhanie ponyatiya i perspeivy v Rossii] // Questions of Juvenile Justice [Voprosy yuvenal’noi yustitsii]. 2007. N 3. P. 3–7. (rus).
17. Kon I.S. Psycology of youth age: problems of formation of the personality [Psikhologiya yunosheskogo vozrasta: Problemy formirovaniya lichnosti]. Tutorial for the student of pedagogic institutes. M.: Education [Prosveshchenie], 1979. (rus).
18. Kotov O. Juvenile justice: historical experience and modern problems [Yuvenal’naya yustitsiya: istoricheskii opyt i sovremennye problem] // Journal of the foreign legislation and comparative jurisprudence [Zhurnal zarubezhnogo zakonodatel’stva i sravnitel’nogo pravovedeniya]. N 5 (24) / Institute of Legislation and Comparative Law under the Government of the Russian Federation [Institut zakonodatel’stva i sravnitel’nogo pravovedeniya pri Pravitel’stve Rossiiskoi Federatsii]. M., 2010. (rus).
19. Lublinsky P. I. Fight against crime in children’s and youth age [Bor’ba s prestupnost’yu v detskom i yunosheskom vozraste]. M.: Legal publishing house of People’s Commissariat of Justice [Yuridicheskoe izd-vo Narkomyusta], 1923. (rus).
20. Merton R. Social consequences of deliberate social action [Sotsial’nye posledstviya prednamerennogo sotsial’nogo deistviya] // Sociological Journal [Sotsiologicheskii zhurnal]. 2009. N 2. P. 6–13. (rus).
21. Orlov V.S. Criminality of minors in the capitalist countries [Prestupnost’ nesovershennoletnikh v kapitalisticheskikh stranakh] / Crime of minors and fight against it in foreign countries [Prestupnost’ nesovershennoletnikh i bor’ba s nei v zarubezhnykh stranakh] / under the editorship of D.S. Karev. M.: Publishing house of the Moscow State University [Iz-vo Mosk. Un-ta], 1961. (rus).
22. Sadovnikova M. N. As the juvenile justice in France works [Kak rabotaet yuvenal’naya yustitsiya vo Frantsii] // Captivity [Nevolya]. 2006. N 8. P. 74–87. (rus).
23. Toure de Coussi, François. The mode of serving of punishment for minors in France [Rezhim otbyvaniya nakazaniya dlya nesovershennoletnikh vo Frantsii] // Questions of Juvenile Justice [Voprosy yuvenal’noi yustitsii]. 2007. N 4 (13). P. 32–39. (rus).
24. Tsinchenko G. M. Juvenile justice as alternative of family ideology [Yuvenal’naya yustitsiya kak al’ternativa semeinoi ideologii] // Health — a basis of human potential: problems and ways of their decision. Works of the VIII Russian scientific and practical conference with the international participation [Zdorov’e — osnova chelovecheskogo potentsiala: problemy i puti ikh resheniya. Trudy VIII Vserossiiskoi nauchno-prakticheskoi konferentsii s mezhdunarodnym uchastiem]. November 21–23, 2013. V. 8, part 1; SPb.: Publishing house of Polytechnical University [Izd-vo Politekhnicheskogo universiteta], 2013. P. 106–108. (rus).
25. Shipunova T.V. Juvenile justice in sociological prospect [Yuvenal’naya yustitsiya v sotsiologicheskoi perspective] // Jurisprudence [Pravovedenie]. SPb., 2001. N 3 (236). P. 178–184. (rus).
26. Schmidt W. Weirded to turbulence: ideas and institutes of protection of children on the former Soviet Union [Obrechennye na turbulentnost’: idei i instituty zashchity detei na postsovetskom prostranstve] // Policy of a family and the childhood in post-socialism [Politika sem’i i detstva v postsotsializme]. M.: JSC Variant: CSPGR [OOO «Variant»: TsSPGI], 2014. 283 p. (rus).
27. Juvenile justice: pro et contra? [Yuvenal’naya yustitsiya: za ili protiv?]. Shorthand report of online conference. Novosibirsk, on January 28, 2010 // Questions of Juvenile Justice [Voprosy yuvenal’noi yustitsii]. 2010. N 3 (29). (rus).
28. Juvenile Justice: project essence [Yuvenal’naya Yustitsiya: sut’ proekta]. M.: Conceptua [Kontseptual], 2011. (rus).
29. Juvenile technologies [Yuvenal’nye tekhnologii]. М.: Russian charity foundation NAN [Rossiiskii blagotvoritel’nyi fond NAN], 2002. (rus).
30. Edvardsson B. Factors in investigative communication with children. 2009. Р. 1. What are the basic problems? URL: http: oru.diva-portal.org/smash/record.jsf?pid=diva2:228065 (дата обра- щения: 09.12.2013).
31. Hardt G. A. Observations on the training of social workers. 1958. http://www.nkmr.org/english/ observations on the training of social workers.htm (дата обращения: 09.12.2013).
32. Madison B. D. Social Welfare in the Soviet Union. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1988.
33. Stilo Simona A. et al. Social disadvantage: Cause or Advance Access published October 22, 2012.
34. Tyrka Audrey R. et al. Childhood Adversity and Epigenetic Modulation of the Leukocyte Glucocorticoid receptor: Preliminary Findings in Healthy Adults. Plos One 7 (1) e30148, 2012.
Review
For citations:
Tsinchenko G.M. Juvenile Justice: Risks of Implementation. Administrative Consulting. 2015;(8):114-127. (In Russ.)
Views:
551
Email this article 