Discursive and Narrative Practices of the Scottish Authorities in the Framework of the Implementation of the Agenda of National and Territorial Self-Determination of Scotland
https://doi.org/10.22394/1726-1139-2023-1-24-33
Abstract
The article analyzes the narrative and discursive practices of political forces aimed at achieving national-territorial sovereignty on the example of Scotland. The authors emphasize the relevance of the task of analyzing the reasons that allow some regions and peoples to be ficult to achieve sovereignty. According to the authors, it is precisely this context that suggests the need for a scientific understanding of the narrative and discursive practices of those political forces that implement the agenda of national-territorial self-determination in the real political process. The purpose of the study is to analyze the narrative and discursive practices of the Scottish Government and the Scottish National Party, the strategy and tactics of which are determined by the peculiarities of Scottish nationalism and the specifics of the identity of the Scots. Research methodology: to achieve this goal, the authors used a set of methods, among which the socio-cultural approach should be particularly noted, which makes it possible in the process of political analysis to consider the socio-political space through the prism of modern world and local civilizational processes, where the political sphere is influenced by socio-cultural factors. As a result of the analysis, the authors came to the conclusion that the discursive and narrative practices of Scottish nationalists contribute to the awareness of indigenous Scots of their own national specifics, which does not conflict with the identities of ethno-confessional minorities living in Scotland.
About the Authors
E. A. TurinRussian Federation
Evgeny A. Turin, Associate Professor of the Chair of History, Political Science and Public Policy, PhD in Political Sciences, Associate Professor
Orel
E. N. Savinova
Russian Federation
Elena N. Savinova, Associate Professor of the Chair of History, Political Science and Public Policy, PhD in Political Sciences, Associate Professor
Orel
M. V. Levochkina
Russian Federation
Margarita V. Levochkina, Postgraduate Student of the Chair of History, Political Science and Public Policy
Orel
References
1. Apryshchenko Yu. V. Scotland in Modern times: in search of identity. Saint Petersburg : Aleteya, 2016. 720 p. EDN VJUBUD (in Rus).
2. Merkulov P. A., Tyurin E. A., Savinova E. N. The evolution of the Scottish National Party in the struggle for national self-determination of Scotland: on the question of the peculiarities of Scottish nationalism // Power [Vlast’]. 2017. Vol. 25. N 6. P. 153–159. EDN YULOLJ (in Rus).
3. Tyurin E. A., Savinova E. N., Pereverzeva O. V. “Soft power” as a socio-cultural resource of the political confrontation between Edinburgh and London // Vestnik of Moscow State Linguistic University. Social sciences [Vestnik Moskovskogo gosudarstvennogo lingvisticheskogo universiteta. Obshchestvennye nauki]. 2021. N 4 (845). P. 118–130. EDN EOXNYD (in Rus).
4. Bechhofer F., McCrone D. National Identity, nationalism and constitutional change. In: National identity, nationalism and constitutional change // Berlin : Springer. 2009. P. 1–16.
5. Brown A., McCrone D., Paterson L., Surridge P. The Scottish electorate: the 1997 // Springer : General Election and Beyond, 1998.
6. Butler J. Bodies that matter: on the discursive limits of sex. Routledge, 2011. 256 p.
7. Davidson N., Liinpää M., McBride M. & Virdee S. No problem here: understanding racism in Scotland. Edinburgh : Luath Press Limited. 2018.
8. Gawlewicz A. “Scotland’s Different”: Narratives of Scotland’s Distinctiveness in the Post BrexitVote Era // Scottish Affairs. 2020. N 29 (3). P. 321–335. DOI:10.3366/scot.2020.0326.
9. Hepburn E., Rosie M. Immigration, nationalism, and politics in Scotland. The politics of immigration in multi — level states. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2014. P. 241–260.
10. Hopkins P. Managing Stranger hood: Young Sikh Men’s Strategies // Environment and Planning A. 2014. N 46 (7). P. 1572–1585. DOI:10.1068/a46263.
11. Hussain A. M., Miller W. L. Multicultural Nationalism: Islamophobia, Anglophobia, and Devolution. Oxford : Oxford University Press on Demand, 2006.
12. Leith M.S. Political discourse and national identity in Scotland. Edinburgh : Edinburgh University Press, 2012.
13. Liinpää M. Nationalism from above and below: Interrogating race, ethnicity and belonging in post-devolutionary Scotland : PhD diss. University of Glasgow, 2018. 293 p.
14. McCrone D. The new sociology of Scotland. London : Sage, 2017.
15. McCrone D. & Bechhofer F. Understanding national identity. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press. Medda-Windischer. 2015.
16. Phipps A., Fassetta G. A Critical Analysis of Language Policy in Scotland // European Journal of Language Policy. 2015. N 7 (1). P. 5–29. DOI:10.22439/fs.v0i16.4116.
17. Sime D. New scots? Eastern European young people’s feelings of belonging and national identity in Scotland post-Brexit // Scottish Affairs. 2020. N 29 (3). P. 336–353. DOI:10.3366/scot.2020.0327.
18. YouGov: Where the public stands on immigration [Electronic source]. URL: https://YouGov.co.uk/topics/politics/articles-reports/2018/04/27/where-public-stands-immigration (accessed: 19.07.2022).
19. YouGov: Scottish independence: Yes leads by 53% to 47% [Electronic source]. URL: https://YouGov.co.uk/topics/politics/articles-reports/2020/08/12/scottish-independence-yes-leads-53-47 (accessed: 19.07.2022).
Review
For citations:
Turin E.A., Savinova E.N., Levochkina M.V. Discursive and Narrative Practices of the Scottish Authorities in the Framework of the Implementation of the Agenda of National and Territorial Self-Determination of Scotland. Administrative Consulting. 2023;(1):24-33. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.22394/1726-1139-2023-1-24-33