“World Nationality” by Eyes of it’s Critics (Five Arguments against “Saturated” Cosmopolitism of M. Nussbaum)
Abstract
The objective of this article is the review and critique of the analysis of global citizenship through the lens of political philosophy of communitarianism, neo-Marxist world-system analysis, liberal nationalism and traditionalism.
About the Author
Sergey Vladimirovich Akopov
National Research University “Higher School of Economics”
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
References
1. Wallerstein I. World-Systems Analysis and a situation in the modern world [Analiz mirovykh sistem i situatsiya v sovremennom mire]. SPb., 2001.
2. Wallerstein I. Neither patriotism, no cosmopolitism [Ni patriotizm, ni kosmopolitizm] // Logos, N. 2(53), 2006. P. 126–127.
3. Nussbaum M. Cosmopolitism and patriotism [Kosmopolitizm i patriotism] // Logos. N 2(53), 2006. P. 110–119.
4. Putnam H. Do we have to choose between patriotism and universal reason? [Dolzhny li my vybirat’ mezhdu patriotizmom i universal’nym razumom?] // Logos. N 2(53), 2006. P. 120–125.
5. Taylor Ch. Why the democracy needs patriotism [Pochemu demokratiya nuzhdaetsya v patriotizme] // Logos. N 2(53), 2006. P. 130–131.
6. Walzer M. Spheres of attachment [Sfery privyazannosti] // Logos. N 2(53), 2006. P. 128–129.
7. Huntington S. Who are We? The Challenges To America’s National Identity [Kto my? Vyzovy amerikanskoi natsional’noi identichnosti]. M., 2004.
8. Calhoun G. The Class Consciousness of Frequent Travelers. Toward a Critique of Actually Existing Cosmopolitanism // South Atlantic Quaterly. 2002. № 101(4). P. 869–897.
9. Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy: Nationalism and Global Justice — David Miller and His Critics. Vol. 11, № 4, 2008.
10. Held D. Cosmopolitanism. Ideas and Realities. London, 2010.
11. Kymlicka W. Citizenship in the Era of Globalization // The Cosmopolitanism Reader / G. W. Brown. D. Held (еds.), Polity, Cambridge, 2010. P. 435–443.
12. Kymlicka W. From Enlightenment Cosmopolitanism to Liberal Nationalism / Politics in the Vernacular: Nationalism, Multiculturalism, and Citizenship. Oxford. 2000. P. 203–220.
13. Kymlicka W. Liberalism. Community and Culture. Oxford. 1991.
14. Miller D. Citizenship and National Identity. Polity, Cambridge. 2000.
15. Miller D. Cosmopolitanism // The Cosmopolitanism Reader / G. W. Brown. D. Held (еds.), Polity, Cambridge, 2010. P. 377–392.
16. Taras R. Europe Old and New: transnationalism, belonging, xenophobia. Lanham, 2009.
Review
For citations:
Akopov S.V. “World Nationality” by Eyes of it’s Critics (Five Arguments against “Saturated” Cosmopolitism of M. Nussbaum). Administrative Consulting. 2015;(2):107-114. (In Russ.)
Views:
666
Email this article 