Three Paradigms of Juridical Knowledge: to Anniversary of Professor A. V. Polyakov
Abstract
Article is dedicated to the 60-year anniversary of the professor of the chair of theory and law history and state of St. Petersburg State University, doctor of juridical sciences Andrey Vasilyevich Polyakov. In the article are analyzed some basic ideas of the communicative theory of law, creator of which is A. V. Polyakov. In this case the communicative theory of law by A. V. Polyakov it is considered in context of the processes, which characterize the development of the juridical science, by which, as for any other sciences, is inherent the sequential change of the paradigms of knowledge. In the article are separated three such paradigms, namely pre-classical, classical and postclassical. The author assumes that ideas of A. V. Polyakov, who is the best-known representative of the post-classical theory of law in Russia, they stimulate the change of the paradigms of lawful knowledge and thus contribute to overcoming crisis phenomena in the juridical science.
About the Author
Nicolay Victorovich Razuvaev
North-West Institute of Management - the branch of Russian of National Economy and State Service
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
References
1. Giddens A. The Constitution of Society: The Outline of Theory of Structration [Ustroenie obshchestva: ocherk teorii strukturatsii]. M. : Academic Project [Akademicheskii proekt], 2005.
2. Grotius G. On the right of war and peace [O prave voiny i mira]. M. : Ladomir, 1994.
3. Husserl E. Ideas to pure phenomenology and phenomenological philosophy. Book One. General of introduction into pure phenomenology [Idei k chistoi fenomenologii i fenomenologicheskoi filosofii. Kniga pervaya. Obshchee vvedeniya v chistuyu fenomenologiyu]. M. : Academic Project [Akademicheskii proekt], 2009.
4. Communicative theory of right and the contemporary problems of jurisprudence [Kommunikativnaya teoriya prava i sovremennye problemy yurisprudentsii] : сollective monograph : in 2 v. / ed. by. M. V. Antonov and I. L. Chestnov. SPb. : Aleph-Press [Izdatel’skii Dom «Alef-Press»], 2014.
5. Kuhn T. Structure of scientific revolutions [Struktura nauchnykh revolyutsii]. M. : Progress [Progress], 1977. 6. Polyakov A. V. The normativeness of juridical communication [Normativnost’ pravovoi kommunikatsii] // Jurisprudence [Pravovedenie]. 2011. № 5. P. 27–45.
6. Polyakov A. V. Farewell to the classics, or as a possible communicative theory of law [Proshchanie s klassikoi, ili kak vozmozhna kommunikativnaya teoriya prava] // Russian annual of the theory of the right [Rossiiskii ezhegodnik teorii prava]. 2008. № 1. SPb. : University’s Publishing Consortium “Juridical Book” [Universitetskii izdatel’skii konsortsium “Yuridicheskaya kniga”], 2009. P. 9–42.
7. Popper K. R. Evolutionary epistemology [Evolyutsionnaya epistemologiya] // Evolutionary epistemology and the logic of social sciences. Karl Popper and its opponents [Evolyutsionnaya epistemologiya i logika sotsial’nykh nauk. Karl Popper i ego kritiki] / ed. by V. N. Sadovsky. M. : Editorial URSS, 2000.
8. Razuvaev N. V. Contemporary theory of law in search of the post-classical paradigm of the knowledge [Sovremennaya teoriya prava v poiskakh postklassicheskoi paradigmy poznaniya] // Jurisprudence [Pravovedenie]. 2014. № 5. P. 136–153.
9. Sartre J.-P. Basic idea of Husserl’s phenomenology: intentionality [Osnovnaya ideya fenomenologii Gusserlya: intentsional’nost’] // Problems of ontology in the contemporary bourgeois philosophy [Problemy ontologii v sovremennoi burzhuaznoi filosofii] / ed. by T. A. Kuzmina. Riga : Zinatne, 1988. P. 318–320.
10. Stammler R. Economy and right from the point of view of the materialist understanding of the history: the social-philosophical study [Khozyaistvo i pravo s tochki zreniya materialisticheskogo ponimaniya istorii: Sotsial’no-filosofskoe issledovanie]. 2nd ed. M. : URSS, 2010.
11. Etzioni A. The Active Society. New York : Free Press, 1968.
12. Giddens A. Central Problem of Social Theory: Action, Structure and Contradiction in Social Analysis. London : Macmillan, 1979.
13. Touraine A. Social Movement and Social Change // The Challenge of Social Change / ed. O. F. Borda. London : Sage, 1985.
Review
For citations:
Razuvaev N.V. Three Paradigms of Juridical Knowledge: to Anniversary of Professor A. V. Polyakov. Administrative Consulting. 2015;(3):60-67. (In Russ.)
Views:
640
Email this article 