Panclavism as Panmongolism. Historiosophy of Nationalism
https://doi.org/10.22394/1726-1139-2017-10-136-149
Abstract
The article discusses the historiosophical journalism of V. S. Solovyov 1890’s. It is proved that V. S. Solovyov to the historical experience of the Asian states (China and Japan) was necessary in order to show the perniciousness of the policy of isolationism and the beneficence of the civilizational dialogue and the borrowing of the achievements of European culture. Historical examples served VS. Soloviev basis for historiosophical generalizations and criticism of the Slavophil philosophy of history, in particular, the concept of N.Ya. Danilevsky. A comparison of the views of V. S. Solovyov with the historical concept of his father S. M. Solovyov. It is shown that, in part, an assessment of the historical role of Asian peoples and the characteristics of the Slavophil movement V. S. Soloviev borrowed from his father.
Keywords
V. S. Solovyov,
historiosophy,
China,
Japan,
isolationism,
civilization,
borrowing,
asiatism,
panmongolism
References
1. Annenkova N. V. Oriental Intentions of Russian Symbolism [Vostochnye intencii russkogo simvolizma] // Discourse-Pi [Diskurs-Pi]. 2004. N 1. P. 39–41. (rus)
2. Brodsky A. I. Vladimir Solovyov [Vladimir Solov’ev]. SPb. : Science, 2017. (rus)
3. Brodsky A. I. Logic of ideologies: From the history of Russian political thought of the XIX–XX centuries [Logika ideologij: Iz istorii russkoj politicheskoj mysli XIX–XX vekov]. SPb., 2006. (rus)
4. Brodsky A. I. Images of fate in n philosophy and literature of the XIX-XX centuries [Obrazy sud’by v russkoj filosofii i literature XIX–XX vekov]. SPb. : Publishing house S.-Petersburg. University, 2011. (rus)
5. Brodsky A. I., Nikonenko V.S. Philosophical interpretation of artistic texts (on the example of Russian literature of the XIX century): Textbook [Filosofskaja interpretacija hudozhestvennyh tekstov (na primere russkoj literatury XIX v.): Uchebnoe posobie]. SPb. : Publishing house S.- Petersburg. University, 2009. (rus)
6. Kupriyanov V. A. The structure of Europe in the philosophical and historical teachings of V.I. Lamansky [Struktura Evropy v filosofsko-istoricheskom uchenii V. I. Lamanskogo] // Veche. Journal of Russian Philosophy and Culture [Veche. Zhurnal russkoj filosofii i kul’tury]. 2016. Vol. 28. P. 215–222. (rus)
7. Marosi V. V. «The Mongolian myth» in Russian literature of the twentieth century [«Mongol›skij mif» v russkoj literature XX veka] // Bulletin of the Tomsk State Pedagogical University [Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo pedagogicheskogo universiteta]. 2003. N 1. P. 48–54. (rus)
8. Molodyakov V. E. East of Xerxes: Japan in the philosophy of the history of V. Solovyov and A. Bely [Vostok Kserksa: Japonija v filosofii istorii V. Solov’jova i A. Belogo] // Problems of the Far East [Problemy Dal’nego Vostoka]. 1991. N 1. P. 61–68. (rus)
9. Molodyakov V. E. The image of Japan in Europe and Russia in the second half of the XIX — early XX century [Obraz Japonii v Evrope i Rossii vtoroj poloviny XIX — nachala XX veka]. M. : Institute of Oriental Studies, Russian Academy of Sciences, 1996. (rus)
10. Serbinenko V. V. Far Eastern theme in n philosophy of the XIX century. (A. Khomyakov, N. Danilevsky, V.S. Solovyov) [Dal’nevostochnaja tema v russkoj filosofii XIX v. (A. Homjakov, N. Danilevskij, V.S. Solov’jov)] // Bulletin of the Russian University of Peoples’ Friendship [Vestnik Rossijskogo universiteta druzhby narodov]. Ser. Philosophy. 1999. N 1. P. 101–111. (rus)
11. Serbinenko V.V. China in n thought of the XIX century (from the utopia of Odoevsky to the eschatology of Solovyov) [Kitaj v russkoj mysli XIX v. (ot utopii Odoevskogo do jeshatologii Solov’jova)] // In the way for the Chinese wall the collection of works: to the 60th anniversary of A.I. Kobzeva [V puti za Kitajskuju stenu sobranie trudov: k 60-letiju A.I. Kobzeva]. M., 2014. P. 420–434. (rus)
12. Serbinenko V.V. The problem of the ratio of Chinese and Japanese cultures in the works of V.S. Solovyov [Problema sootnoshenija kitajskoj i japonskoj kul’tur v tvorchestve V.S. Solov’jova] // XV Scientific Conference «Society and the State in China»: theses and reports [XV nauchnaja konferencija «Obshhestvo i gosudarstvo v Kitae»: tez. i dokl].Vol. 1. M. : Science, 1984. P. 26–34. (rus)
13. Serbinenko V.V. The dispute about China: Vl. Soloviev and N. Danilevsky [Spor o Kitae: Vl. Solov’ev i N. Danilevskij] // Notes on conservatism [Tetradi po konservatizmu]. 2015. N 5. P. 39–48. (rus)
14. Setnitsky N. A. Russian thinkers about China (N. F. Fedorov and V. S. Solovyov) [Russkie mysliteli o Kitae (N. F. Fjodorov i V.S. Solov’jov)] // Proceedings of the Faculty of Law [Izvestija juridicheskogo fakul’teta]. Harbin : Dawn, 1926. P. 191–222. (rus)
15. Skorokhodova S. I. Asia in n philosophy of the XIX century [Azija v russkoj filosofii XIX v.] // Solov’ev’s research [Solov’evskie issledovanija]. 2016. N 1. P. 26–43. (rus)
16. Soloviev V.S. Byzantinism and Russia [Vizantizm i Rossija] // V.S. Soloviev. Collected works [Sobranie sochinenij]. In 10 v. Vol. 7. SPb., 1912. P. 285–328. (rus)
17. Soloviev V.S. Enemy from the East [Vrag s Vostoka] // V.S. Soloviev Works in 2 v. [Sochinenija v 2 t.].Vol. 2. M. : Thought, 1990. P. 480–492. (rus)
18. Soloviev V.S. From the philosophy of history [Iz filosofii istorii] // V.S. Soloviev. Collected works [Sobranie sochinenij]. In 10 v. Vol. 6. SPb., 1912. P. 340–362. (rus)
19. Soloviev V.S. China and Europe [Kitaj i Evropa] // V. S. Soloviev. Collected works [Sobranie sochinenij]. In 10 v. Vol. 6. SPb., 1912. P. 93–152. (rus)
20. Soloviev V.S. The World of East and West [Mir Vostoka i Zapada] // V. S. Soloviev Collected works [Sobranie sochinenij]. In the 10 v. Vol. 7. SPb., 1912. P. 381–384. (rus)
21. Soloviev V. S. The national question in Russia. Issue one. 1883–1888 [Nacional’nyj vopros v Rossii. Vypusk pervyj. 1883–1888] // V. S. Soloviev. Collected works [Sobranie sochinenij]. In 10 v. Vol. 5. SPb., 1912. P. 3–153. (rus)
22. Soloviev V.S. Three Conversations on War, Progress and the End of World History [Tri razgovora o vojne, progresse i konce vsemirnoj istorii] // V. S. Soloviev. Works in 2 v. [Sochinenija v 2 t.].Vol. 2. M. : Thought, 1990. P. 635–762. (rus)
23. Soloviev V. S. Japan (Historical characteristics) [Japonija (Istoricheskaja harakteristika)] // V.S. Soloviev. Collected works [Sobranie sochinenij]. In 10 v. Vol. 6. SPb., 1912. P. 153–173. (rus)
24. Soloviev S. M. Historical letters [Istoricheskie pis’ma] // S. M. Soloviev. Selected works. Notes [Izbrannye trudy. Zapiski]. M., 1983. P. 180–228. (rus)
25. Soloviev S. M. History of Russia since ancient times. Vol. 13 [Istorija Rossii s drevnejshih vremen. T. 13] // S. M. Soloviev Compositions. Book VII. [Sochinenija. Kniga VII]. M., 1991. (rus)
26. Soloviev S. M. Works in 18 books. Book I. Vol. 1–2. The history of Russia from ancient times [Sochinenija v 18 kn. Kn. I. T. 1–2. Istorija Rossii s drevnejshih vremeni]. M. : Thought, 1993. (rus)
27. Chach E. A. The Oriental Context of the Silver Age [Oriental’nyj kontekst Serebrjanogo veka] // Omsk Scientific Bulletin [Omskij nauchnyj vestnik]. 2010. N 1. P. 59–62. (rus)
Review
For citations:
Malinov A.V. Panclavism as Panmongolism. Historiosophy of Nationalism. Administrative Consulting. 2017;(10):136-149. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.22394/1726-1139-2017-10-136-149
Views:
745
Email this article 