The Formation of Planning in Russia in the 1920s and Modern Realities
https://doi.org/10.22394/1726-1139-2022-12-100-112
Abstract
The formation of a modern system of strategic planning requires taking into account the accumulated experience of the Soviet period of Russian history. The studies of the 1920s deserve special attention. It is of interest to compare the genetic and teleological approaches to planning. The first involves taking into account the influence of various factors and the preparation of various options for plans. The second is based on the need to establish targets and indicators, to solve urgent and large-scale problems of the national economy. The experience of research in the 1920s and the results of the implementation of the plans of the Soviet period, as well as the experience of the formation of strategic planning of the modern period of Russian history, testify to the need for a comprehensive consideration of various approaches in organizing planning.
About the Authors
M. Yu. Elsukov
Russian Academy of National Economy and Public Administration under the President of the Russian Federation (North-Western Institute of Management RANEPA)
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Mikhail Yu. Elsukov, Associate Professor of the Chair of Economics and Finance, Candidate of Geographical Sciences, Associate Professor
St. Petersburg
N. N. Kirillova
Russian Academy of National Economy and Public Administration under the President of the Russian Federation (North-Western Institute of Management RANEPA)
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Nadezhda N. Kirillova, Postgraduate Student of the Chair of Economics, Lecturer of the Chair of Management
St. Petersburg
References
1. Alter L.B., Braginsky B. I. Economic laws and improvement of national economy planning. M. : Economics, 1970. 151 p. (In Rus).
2. Amosov A. I. Socio-economic evolution of Russia. M. : ROSSPEN, 2004. 183 p. (in Rus).
3. Bazarov V. A. To the methodology of long-term planning. State planned commission at STO. M. : Gosplan, 1924. 16 p. (In Rus).
4. Bazarov V. A. Capitalist cycles and the recovery process of the economy of the USSR. M.; L. : State Publishing House, 1927. 168 p. (In Rus).
5. Bazarov V.A. On the methodology for constructing long-term plans // Planned economy [Planovoe khozyaistvo]. 1926. N 7. P. 9–10 (In Rus).
6. Bazarov V. A. Principles of building a long-term plan // Planned economy [Planovoe khozyaistvo]. 1928. N 2. P. 7–21 (In Rus).
7. Bozhenova S. I. Economic views of scientists-economists of the 20–30s of the twentieth century on the problems of the formation and development of planning: PhD Dissertation. SPb. : St. Petersburg State University of Economics, 2021. 173 p. (In Rus).
8. Weisberg R. “Objective” science of pest planners // Bolshevik. 1930. N 19–20. P. 3–41 (In Rus).
9. Valishevskaya T. I. Features of the development of the methodology of domestic planning // Bulletin of the OSU [Vestnik OGU]. 2014. N 8 (169). P. 3–9 (In Rus).
10. Vilisov M. V. The role of legislation on strategic planning in the sphere of public policy // Power [Vlast’]. 2016. N 6. P. 7–14 (In Rus).
11. Gvozdetsky V. L. GOELRO plan. Myths and reality // Science and life [Nauka i zhizn’]. 2001. N 5. P. 102–109 (In Rus).
12. Glaz’ev S.Yu., Mikerin G. I., Teslya P. N., Kovaleva G. D., Nikolov I. G. Long waves: scientific and technological progress and socio-economic development. Novosibirsk : Nauka, 1991. 224 p. (In Rus).
13. Granberg A. G. V. Leontiev and his contribution to world economic science // The Economist [Ekonomist[. 2007. N 2. P. 11–18 (In Rus).
14. Gretchenko A. I., Gorohova I. V. Planning experience of the USSR and the problems of strategic planning in modern Russia // Vestnik of the Plekhanov Russian University of Economics [Vestnik REU im. Plekhanova]. 2014. N 11 (77). P. 70–80 (In Rus).
15. Elsukov M.Yu. On the prospects for strategic planning of the socio-economic development of Russia // State and business. Modern problems and trends in the development of the regional economy: Proceedings of the XIV International Scientific and Practical Conference. In 2 parts, St. Petersburg, April 21–22, 2022. SPb. : North-Western Institute of Management — branch of the RANEPA, 2021. P. 51–62 (In Rus).
16. Elsukov M.Yu. Actual directions of innovative development: domestic and foreign research experience / M. Yu. Elsukov, A. P. Isaev // Trends of globalization. SPb. : Publishing and Printing Center of the SZIU RANEPA, 2022. P. 225–247 (In Rus).
17. Kadifov V. V. Modern methodological approaches to strategic management and development of cities of various types. Moscow: Publishing house “Delo” RANEPA, 2015. 246 p. (in Rus).
18. Kazantsev N. M. Lapsuses of Federal Law N 172-FZ “On Strategic Planning in the Russian Federation” // Innovations [Innovatsii]. 2018. N 8 (238). P. 24–32 (In Rus).
19. Klebaner V.S. V. A. Bazarov thinker, scientist, citizen // Problems of Forecasting [Problemy prognozirovaniya]. 2004. N 6. P. 150–156 (In Rus).
20. Kolganov A. I. Soviet planning: what and why is relevant in the 21st century // Economic science of modern Russia [Ekonomicheskaya nauka sovremennoi Rossii]. 2021. N 4. P. 127–132 (In Rus).
21. Korovnikova N.A. Modern Russian economists about the Soviet economic thought of the 1920s // Social and humanitarian sciences: Domestic and foreign literature. Ser. 2, Economics: Abstract journal. 2019. N 4. P. 7–12 (In Rus).
22. Marshev V. I. History of managerial thought: a textbook. M. : INFRA-M, 2005. 731 p. (In Rus).
23. Nemchinov V.S. On the further improvement of planning and management of the national economy. M. : Publishing house of economic literature, 1964. 307 p. (In Rus).
24. Pogrebinskaya V. A. Russian strategic planning experience // Russian Entrepreneurship [Rossiiskoe predprinimatel’stvo]. 2016. Vol. 17. N 14. P. 1629–1644 (In Rus).
25. Russian doctrines as acts of state administration: monograph / S. S. Sulakshin and others. M. : Scientific expert, 2012. 148 p. (In Rus).
26. Fedorenko N. P. On the development of a system for the optimal functioning of the economy. M. : Nauka, 1968. 243 p. (In Rus).
27. Khodachek V. M. National strategic planning as a condition for the sustainable development of the Russian economy // Administrative Consulting. Actual problems of state and municipal management [Upravlencheskoe konsul’tirovanie. Aktual’nye problemy gosudarstvennogo i munitsipal’nogo upravleniya]. 2009. N 4 (36). P. 96–103 (In Rus).
28. Chistobaev A. I. Plots from the practice of managing the development of territories in the USSR and modern Russia // Socio-economic geography. Bulletin of the Association of Russian social geographers [Sotsial’no-ekonomicheskaya geografiya. Vestnik Assotsiatsii rossiiskikh geografov-obshchestvovedov]. 2018. N 7. P. 13–24 (In Rus).
Review
For citations:
Elsukov M.Yu., Kirillova N.N. The Formation of Planning in Russia in the 1920s and Modern Realities. Administrative Consulting. 2022;(12):100-112. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.22394/1726-1139-2022-12-100-112
Views:
379
Email this article 